logo Satuki @ Home

Trade to win

Sign up for my latest trading ideas. Free!

A Primer on Shorting

Posted by Satuki On March - 15 - 2009

In trading, shorting stocks is referring to try to profit from falling stocks. From day one in school, you were taught all kind of wonderful investment strategies such as buy low and sell high or buy higher and sell higher (my strategy).   It sounds very unnatural to profit from falling stocks.   Nevertheless, Shorting is a genius idea.   If you ask me, nothing in the financial world comes close to allowing short selling.   It simply is a splendid idea for speculators like you and me. 

 

This will never happen in any places other than trading. When you buy a piece of real estate and hold onto it for a few years, you sell it for a profit if it has appreciated over the years.   It is all sound and good.   What if you go tell a housing developer to lend you a piece of real estate and sell it in 2007, buy it back in 2009, give him back the real estate and you keep the difference?     He would think you are just out of your mind.  He also must think you are one crook because you profit from his pains.   So in real life, you can not ask someone to lend you something and short sell it for a profit even if it is a technically sound idea.

 

However, you can enjoy shorting here in the stock market.  In order to short stocks, you will have to borrow stocks from your broker.  Your broker normally keeps a constant ratio between the number of shares shorted and the total number of shares in his inventory.   Let’s say that number is 40%.   Then it will be hard to borrow the stock to short once the number reaches that level.  That is why you can not short some stocks sometimes.  And you can short them again after a little while.  If a broker loans you any shares to short without any inventory, it is called “naked shorting”, which is illegal.

Here are a few unique characteristics about shorting

  1. When a stock drops, it tends to move much faster than when it goes up. Here is why. In reality, the bulls far outnumber the bears since people are taught that shorts are unethical and you should be investing instead of speculating, blah, blah…  Therefore, when a stock goes down, there are a lot of panicked bulls that trample each other, thus cause a stock to drop very fast.
  2. Stocks can drop on their own weight.  Have you seen stocks that drop a little bit every day without any volume for a long time?   Sellers (shorts and panicked bulls) just gradually pile on each other every day.   However, stocks seldom go up without any significant buying power and volume. Only cornered stocks would move withou any volume.
  3. If you short a penny stock, it might gap up 500% tomorrow morning, which is very rare.  In addition, you should be fine if you keep your positions small   However, the most you can lose in a long position is 100%, which is also very rare.

 

Shorting is not for everyone.  As I said many times, you do not have to know how to short stocks to be a great trader.  You can be a great net long trader as long as you know when to stay out of the market when it is getting ugly.


Would you like to receive the latest trading ideas or other updates from my blog? Then join hundreds of others on my mailing list below. It is totally free and easy to opt-out.

Enter your email address:


Most Commented Posts


  • Daniel

    Can you explain more how can one do shorting? For instance, with buying stocks you can use TD, ScottTrade, etc where you pay fixed comission per trade. How does it work with shorting? Is there a place online to do it?

    • http://www.momdaytrader.com/blog/ Satuki (Trader Mom)

      You can also short stocks with TD, ScottTrade and any reputable brokers. All brokers require margin accounts. So you basically need to tell them to upgrade your cash account to margin account. Please note that you will have to pay interest if you hold your short positions overnight.

  • Daniel

    Can you explain more how can one do shorting? For instance, with buying stocks you can use TD, ScottTrade, etc where you pay fixed comission per trade. How does it work with shorting? Is there a place online to do it?

    • http://www.momdaytrader.com Trader Mom

      You can also short stocks with TD, ScottTrade and any reputable brokers. All brokers require margin accounts. So you basically need to tell them to upgrade your cash account to margin account. Please note that you will have to pay interest if you hold your short positions overnight.

  • David

    Hi Satuki,

    I don’t have a comment about shorting, but hope you don’t mind a few general questions about trading.

    I have been looking at my watch-list for the last two weeks, almost confounded by the upturn the market has taken. I haven’t entered a trade because, frankly, I feel almost paralyzed. Given the depressed world economy, I keep thinking this rally can’t possibly last more than a few days, hence my hesitation to enter. Now we are nearing the end of the second week of this rally, and I still have cold feet.

    Do you ever react like that?! It’s really disheartening. On one hand I am apprehensive because I feel the market will surely plummet again. On the other hand, I feel that I am possibly missing out on what could be a sustained bull run. What a terrible, helpless feeling.

    Anyhow, 3 questions:

    1) Are you ever immobilized by how the market’s behaving, to the point where you don’t enter trades?
    2) Does “news” impact what your technical analysis data tells you SHOULD happen?
    3) Do you think the current rally will run out of steam/has the bottom been realized?

    Thanks!

    • http://www.momdaytrader.com/blog/ Satuki (Trader Mom)

      1) Are you ever immobilized by how the market’s behaving, to the point where you don’t enter trades?
      >> Never, Market always gives you surprises. Do not feel helpless. There is no way you can catch all the moves.

      2) Does “news” impact what your technical analysis data tells you SHOULD happen?
      >> News definitely has impact on my TA. No one can predict news. No TA can foretell news. But that is OK since my stop loss orders will take of it.

      3) Do you think the current rally will run out of steam/has the bottom been realized?
      >> I do not think we are seeing a major reversal from here. Why is this rally different than any other sucker rallies before? At least I do not see any signs for now.

  • David

    Hi Satuki,

    I don’t have a comment about shorting, but hope you don’t mind a few general questions about trading.

    I have been looking at my watch-list for the last two weeks, almost confounded by the upturn the market has taken. I haven’t entered a trade because, frankly, I feel almost paralyzed. Given the depressed world economy, I keep thinking this rally can’t possibly last more than a few days, hence my hesitation to enter. Now we are nearing the end of the second week of this rally, and I still have cold feet.

    Do you ever react like that?! It’s really disheartening. On one hand I am apprehensive because I feel the market will surely plummet again. On the other hand, I feel that I am possibly missing out on what could be a sustained bull run. What a terrible, helpless feeling.

    Anyhow, 3 questions:

    1) Are you ever immobilized by how the market’s behaving, to the point where you don’t enter trades?
    2) Does “news” impact what your technical analysis data tells you SHOULD happen?
    3) Do you think the current rally will run out of steam/has the bottom been realized?

    Thanks!

    • http://www.momdaytrader.com Trader Mom

      1) Are you ever immobilized by how the market’s behaving, to the point where you don’t enter trades?
      >> Never, Market always gives you surprises. Do not feel helpless. There is no way you can catch all the moves.

      2) Does “news” impact what your technical analysis data tells you SHOULD happen?
      >> News definitely has impact on my TA. No one can predict news. No TA can foretell news. But that is OK since my stop loss orders will take of it.

      3) Do you think the current rally will run out of steam/has the bottom been realized?
      >> I do not think we are seeing a major reversal from here. Why is this rally different than any other sucker rallies before? At least I do not see any signs for now.


Twitter: Follow Trader Mom
RSS Feed: Subscribe in a reader





Page optimized by WP Minify WordPress Plugin